| 2009 Baseball All Conference | ||
| Player of the Year: Andrew Bauer | Arrowhead | Junior |
| 1st Team | ||
| Pitcher | ||
| Jordan Paszek | Arrowhead | Junior |
| Justin Mortensen | Arrowhead | Senior |
| Catcher | ||
| Tyler Brusky | Pius XI | Junior |
| 1st Baseman | ||
| Brian Crook | Arrowhead | Junior |
| Infielders | ||
| Andrew Bauer | Arrowhead | Senior |
| Chris Pendergast | Arrowhead | Senior |
| Nic Stanczyk | Waukesha South | Senior |
| Outfielders | ||
| Josh Henkel | Arrowhead | Senior |
| Derek Peake | Catholic Memorial | Junior |
| Scott Trojan | Mukwonago | Senior |
| Utility | ||
| Brent Williams | Kettle Moraine | Senior |
| Ryan Solberg | Waukesha West | Junior |
| 2nd Team | ||
| Pitcher | ||
| Ben Rademacher | Kettle Moraine | Senior |
| Jameson Sadowske | Mukwonago | Junior |
| Catcher | ||
| Karl Sprung | Arrowhead | Senior |
| 1st Baseman | ||
| Anthony Kozinski | Pius XI | Senior |
| Infielders | ||
| Joe Scheibe | Mukwonago | Senior |
| Thomas Mayhew | Pius XI | Junior |
| Ian Riebe | Waukesha West | Senior |
| Outfielders | ||
| Ryan Passaglia | Arrowhead | Senior |
| Wes Stasik | Catholic Memorial | Senior |
| Chris Hayden | Kettle Moraine | Senior |
| Utility | ||
| John Dobson | Waukesha North | Junior |
| Dan Wilson | Mukwonago | Junior |
| Honorable Mention | ||
| Josh Johns | Mukwonago | Junior |
| Aaron Jushka | Waukesha West | Sophomore |
| Catcher | ||
| Justin Yute | Kettle Moraine | Freshman |
| Josh Tanguay | Mukwonago | Junior |
| 1st Baseman | ||
| Matt Wimmer | Waukesha South | Junior |
| Infielders | ||
| Matt Mayoras | Arrowhead | Senior |
| David Galando | Kettle Moraine | Senior |
| Matt Kress | Pius XI | Senior |
| Steve Petersen | Waukesha North | Junior |
| Outfielders | ||
| Connor Harmann | Arrowhead | Junior |
| Dan Wilson | Mukwonago | Junior |
| Aaron Gendrich | Waukesha North | Junior |
| Mark Brandt | Waukesha South | Junior |
| Adam Holzwart | Waukesha South | Junior |