| 2008-09 Boys Basketball All Conference | ||
| Player of the Year: TJ Bray | Catholic Memorial | Junior |
| 1st Team | ||
| Russell Finco | Arrowhead | Junior |
| Ben Mills | Arrowhead | Junior |
| Dan Kelm | Kettle Moraine | Senior |
| Tyler Bauschek | Mukwonago | Junior |
| Brian Washington | Waukesha South | Senior |
| 2nd Team | ||
| Jack Fleming | Catholic Memorial | Senior |
| Tom Wenzler | Kettle Moraine | Senior |
| Derek Hasanoglu | Mukwonago | Sophomore |
| Matt Becker | Waukesha North | Senior |
| Nate Wood | Waukesha North | Junior |
| Honorable Mention | ||
| Andy Fox | Arrowhead | Junior |
| Charlie Fischer | Arrowhead | Sophomore |
| Mike Neary | Catholic Memorial | Junior |
| Derek Schell | Catholic Memorial | Junior |
| Josh Luterbach | Kettle Moraine | Senior |
| Artie Turner | Pius XI | Junior |
| Jacob Hoppe | Pius XI | Junior |
| Steve Petersen | Waukesha North | Junior |
| Kevin Kuhtz | Waukesha North | Junior |
| Brett Brilowski | Waukesha North | Senior |
| Derek Staffeldt | Waukesha South | Senior |
| Tim Woodford | Waukesha South | Sophomore |
| Robert Davis | Waukesha South | Senior |
| Ryan Solberg | Waukesha West | Junior |
| Ian Riebe | Waukesha West | Senior |