| 2009 Hockey All Conference | ||
| Player of the Year: Connor McBride | Arrowhead | Senior |
| Forwards 1st Team | ||
| Dave Clark | Arrowhead | Senior |
| Brian Berger | Arrowhead | Senior |
| Devin Stuermer | Memorial/Pius | Senior |
| Forwards 2nd Team | ||
| Trent Nienas | Memorial/Pius | Senior |
| Cody Mertens | KM/Muk | Senior |
| Luke Whitlow | Waukesha | Senior |
| Forwards Honorable Mention | ||
| Kyle Fink | Mem/Pius | Sophomore |
| Lukas Nelson | KM/Muk | Senior |
| Danny Simandl | KM/Muk | Senior |
| Nate Freeman | KM/Muk | Junior |
| Ben Marquardt | Oconomowoc | Senior |
| Max Carrigan | Waukesha | Junior |
| Carl Mazzolini | Kenosha | Senior |
| Jimmy Shank | Greendale | Senior |
| Defense 1st Team | ||
| Alex Amundson | Brookfield | Senior |
| Sam Frank | KM/Muk | Senior |
| Defense 2nd Team | ||
| Tom Chapin | Memorial/Pius | Junior |
| Blain Disrud | KM/Muk | Senior |
| Defense Honorable Mention | ||
| Chris Palmer | Arrowhead | Senior |
| Donovan Blakney | Arrowhead | Junior |
| Alex Broderick | Arrowhead | Senior |
| Anthony Soo Hoo | Memorial/Pius | Sophomore |
| Jordan Fuller | Waukesha | Senior |
| Cole Thompson | Kenosha | Sophomore |
| Goalkeeper 1st Team | ||
| Nick Kohn | Arrowhead | Senior |
| Goalkeeper 2nd Team | ||
| David Chapin | Memorial/Pius | Junior |
| Goalkeeper Honorable Mention | ||
| Colin Robinson | KM/Muk | Senior |
| Michael Parda | Waukesha | Junior |