| 2009 Girls Basketball All Conference | ||
| Player of the Year: Krissie Fehly | Mukwonago | Senior |
| 1st Team | ||
| Elizabeth Guhl | Catholic Memorial | Junior |
| Samantha Pfeifer | Kettle Moraine | Junior |
| Briana Radowicz | Mukwonago | Senior |
| Kelly Frings | Pius XI | Junior |
| Katy Allen | Waukesha South | Sophomore |
| 2nd Team | ||
| Anna Luterbach | Kettle Moraine | Sophomore |
| Morgan Lamberg | Mukwonago | Junior |
| Shannon Perez | Mukwonago | Junior |
| Molly Sydnor | Pius XI | Sophomore |
| Eileen VanHorn | Waukesha South | Freshman |
| Honorable Mention | ||
| Alana Merkow | Arrowhead | Senior |
| Jessica Goetz | Arrowhead | Sophomore |
| Rachel White | Catholic Memorial | Senior |
| Karly Lentz | Catholic Memorial | Sophomore |
| Rachel Kerzner | Kettle Moraine | Senior |
| Emily Romdenne | Mukwonago | Junior |
| Terri Bender | Pius XI | Freshman |
| Tierra Bender | Pius XI | Sophomore |
| Brinn Becker | Waukesha South | Sophomore |
| Katie Switalski | Waukesha West | Senior |
| Lauren Demski | Waukesha West | Senior |