| 2009 Girls Soccer All Conference | ||
| Player of the year: Valerie Gonyo | Catholic Memorial | Sophomore |
| 1st Team Forwards | ||
| Amanda Leach | Waukesha North | Senior |
| Holly Lesperance | Waukesah South | Freshman |
| Katie Richter | Waukesha West | Senior |
| 2nd Team Forwards | ||
| Carly Cech | Arrowhead | Sophomore |
| Ellen Chamberlin | Catholic Memorial | Junior |
| Leah Seib | Waukesha West | Sophomore |
| Honorable Mention Forwards | ||
| Rachel Elliott | Kettle Moraine | Senior |
| Meagan Wanecke | Kettle Moraine | Senior |
| Callan Guth | Waukesha South | Senior |
| 1st Team Midfielders | ||
| Amy Kauffung | Arrowhead | Sophomore |
| Amy Zelko | Catholic Memorial | Senior |
| Nikki Condit | Catholic Memorial | Sophomore |
| Megan Braatz | Waukesha South | Senior |
| Jenn Flood | Waukesha West | Sophomore |
| 2nd Team Midfielders | ||
| Amy Bennett | Catholic Memorial | Junior |
| Lauren Strahler | Kettle Moraine | Senior |
| Briana Radowicz | Mukwonago | Senior |
| Kelly Denk | Waukesha West | Junior |
| Honorable Mention Midfielders | ||
| Kelsie Golabowski | Catholic Memorial | Junior |
| Melissa Leister | Kettle Moraine | Junior |
| Brynn Bennett | Pius XI | Sophomore |
| Angie Berens | Waukesha West | Sophomore |
| 1st Team Defense | ||
| Annie Kalscheuer | Catholic Memorial | Sophomore |
| Danielle Grall | Waukesha North | Senior |
| Lauren Demski | Waukesha West | Senior |
| 2nd Team Defense | ||
| Kara Novotny | Catholic Memorial | Junior |
| Brittany Blinkewitz | Mukwonago | Senior |
| Emily Francione | Waukesha North | Senior |
| Amanda Pascavis | Waukesha South | Senior |
| Honorable Mention Defense | ||
| Kristin Ruekert | Catholic Memorial | Senior |
| Monica Gonyo | Catholic Memorial | Sophomore |
| Devon Ellena | Kettle Moraine | Senior |
| Maria Alioto | Pius XI | Freshman |
| 1st Team Goalie | ||
| Kelly Frings | Pius | Junior |
| Aubrey Buehler | Waukesha North | Senior |
| Honorable Mention Goalie | ||
| Greta Davis | Catholic Memorial | Freshman |
| Leah Schwalbach | Mukwonago | Junior |