| 2009 Softball All Conference | ||
| Player of the Year: Clare Blake | Pius | Senior |
| 1st Team Pitcher | ||
| Jami Kessenich | Arrowhead | Senior |
| 2nd Team Pitcher | ||
| Megan Melbye | Kettle Moraine | Junior |
| Honorable Mention Pitcher | ||
| Meredith Dentice | Catholic Memorial | Senior |
| Alyssa Hink | Waukesha North | Senior |
| Amy Drewicz | Waukesha West | Sophomore |
| 1st Team Catcher | ||
| Sam Hastings | Waukesha West | Junior |
| 2nd Team Catcher | ||
| Brodi Ott | Mukwonago | Senior |
| Honorable Mention Catcher | ||
| Emily Mayer | Arrowhead | Senior |
| Kristina Rodriguez | Catholic Memorial | Junior |
| Whitney Williams | Kettle MOraine | Junior |
| Marissa Mader | Waukesha South | Junior |
| 1st Team 1st Baseman | ||
| Cassie Scheel | Arrowhead | Senior |
| 2nd Team 1st Baseman | ||
| Haley Schreiner | Catholic Memorial | Senior |
| Honorable Mention 1st Baseman | ||
| Sam Munich | Kettle Moraine | Junior |
| Alyssa Hoppe | Pius XI | Sophomore |
| 1st Team Infielder | ||
| Sam Pfiefer | Kettle Moraine | Junior |
| Chelsea Gulbronson | Pius XI | Junior |
| Cara Landherr | Waukesha West | Senior |
| 2nd Team Infielder | ||
| Natalie Wasilczuk | Arrowhead | Senior |
| Katie McCann | Kettle Moraine | Sophomore |
| Katie Landherr | Waukesha West | Sophomore |
| Honorable Mention Infielder | ||
| Jordy Brengosz | Arrowhead | Sophomore |
| Lauren Krolikowski | Catholic Memorial | Freshman |
| Candace Rupnick | Kettle Moraine | Sophomore |
| Sierra Flury | Mukwonago | Sophomore |
| Eileen Van Horn | Waukesha South | Freshman |
| Erika Johnson | Waukesha South | Junior |
| Kelly Sykes | Waukesha North | Freshman |
| Dannie Daluge | Waukesha North | Freshman |
| 1st Team Outfielder | ||
| Megan Ritzert | Arrowhead | Junior |
| Allie Wojciechowski | Arrowhead | Senior |
| Jamie Mueller | Waukesha West | Senior |
| 2nd Team Outfielder | ||
| Shelbey Hartig | Kettle Moraine | Junior |
| Kathryn Sulik | Pius XI | Senior |
| Kayla Schafer | Waukesha West | Senior |
| Honorable Mention Outfielder | ||
| Cassie Galentine | Catholic Memorial | Senior |
| Sara Mlsna | Catholic Memorial | Senior |
| Brianne Buerger | Catholic Memorial | Senior |
| Amanda Braun | Pius XI | Junior |
| Kassi Carlsen | Waukesha South | Junior |
| 1st Team Utility | ||
| Rebecca Holzbauer | Pius XI | Sophomore |
| 2nd Team Utility | ||
| Kelsie Knutson | Waukesha North | Freshman |
| Honorable Mention Utility | ||
| Kelly Venzke | Waukesha South | Freshman |