| 2009 Football All Conference | |||
| Offensive Player of the Year | |||
| Ryan Young | Waukesha West | Senior | |
| Defensive Player of the Year | |||
| Matt Boerner | Arrowhead | Senior | |
| Coach of the Year | |||
| Steve Rux | Waukesha West | ||
| Asst Coach of the Year | |||
| John Burton | Waukesha West | ||
| Offense | |||
| 1st Team | |||
| Center | |||
| Matt Losiniecki | Waukesha West | Junior | |
| Guard | |||
| Matt Baldwin | Catholic Memorial | Junior | |
| Alex Krason | Waukesha West | Senior | |
| Tackle | |||
| Jacob Krause | Catholic Memorial | Senior | |
| Chris Busbey | Waukesha West | Junior | |
| Receivers | |||
| Russ Finco | Arrowhead | Senior | |
| Nick Tehan | Waukesha West | Junior | |
| Running Back | |||
| Brian Crook | Arrowhead | Senior | |
| Pete Karczewski | Catholic Memorial | Junior | |
| Charles Congdon | Waukesha West | Senior | |
| Quarterback | |||
| Ryan Young | Waukesha West | Senior | |
| Placekicker | |||
| Derek Peake | Catholic Memorial | Senior | |
| 2nd Team | |||
| Center | |||
| Caleb Krause | Catholic Memorial | Sophomore | |
| Guard | |||
| Jake Lindenberg | Arrowhead | Junior | |
| Ben Brusko | Waukesha West | Senior | |
| Tackle | |||
| Zack Degner | Catholic Memorial | Junior | |
| Ben Jensen | Mukwonago | Senior | |
| Kevin Kuhtz | Waukesha North | Senior | |
| Receivers | |||
| Austin Pucylowski | Catholic Memorial | Senior | |
| Steve Peterson | Waukesha North | Senior | |
| Running Back | |||
| Colton Sweitzer | Arrowhead | Junior | |
| Garret Wescott | Ketle Moraine | Senio | |
| Josh Tanguay | Mukwonago | Senior | |
| Quarterback | |||
| Tom Parish | Arrowhead | Senior | |
| Placekicker | |||
| Everett Scott | Kettle Moraine | Senior | |
| Honorable Mention | |||
| Center | |||
| Austin Gatchel | Arrowhead | Sophomore | |
| Guard | |||
| Tom LaPlante | Kettle Moraine | Senior | |
| Tackle | |||
| Brad Fisher | Arrowhead | Senior | |
| Jon Coon | Pius XI | Junior | |
| Ulice Payne | Pius XI | Junior | |
| Receivers | |||
| Sam Campbell | Kettle Moraine | Senior | |
| Joe Schilz | Pius XI | Senior | |
| Joe Webb | Waukesha North | Junior | |
| Lewis Smith | Waukesha South | Junior | |
| Nathan Angles | Waukesh West | Senior | |
| Andy Laurin | Waukesha West | Senior | |
| Running Back | |||
| Thomas Mayhew | Pius XI | Senior | |
| Kevin MacCudden | Waukesha West | Junior | |
| Quarterback | |||
| Kyle Kita | Kettle Moraine | Sophomore | |
| Derek Hasanoglu | Mukwonago | Junior | |
| Jared Russo | Pius XI | Senior | |
| Chris Aho | Waukesha North | Senior | |
| Placekicker | |||
| Drew Meyer | Arrowhead | Junior | |
| Darin Howell | Mukwonago | Junior | |
| Defense | |||
| 1st Team | |||
| Interior Lineman | |||
| Aaron Pomeroy | Arrowhead | Senior | |
| Charlie | Tell | Catholic Memorial | Senior |
| Breyon Cosey | Waukesha West | Senior | |
| Defensive End | |||
| Blake Mattson | Arrowhead | Junior | |
| Matt Losinicki | Waukesha West | Junior | |
| Linebacker | |||
| Matt Boerner | Arrohead | Senior | |
| Steve Dejewski | Catholic Memorial | Senior | |
| Dave Anderson | Waukesha West | Senior | |
| Secondary | |||
| Jeremy Oleniczak | Arrowhead | Senior | |
| Derek Peake | Catholic Memorial | Senior | |
| Kerwin McKay | Kettle Moraine | Senior | |
| Punter | |||
| Austin Pucylowski | Catholic Memorial | Junior | |
| 2nd Team | |||
| Interior Lineman | |||
| Mike Silas | Catholic Memorial | Senior | |
| Ryan Lau | Catholic Memorial | Junior | |
| Matt Haas | Waukesha West | Senior | |
| Defensive End | |||
| Cody Gardetto | Catholic Memorial | Junior | |
| Ryan Vonck | Waukesha West | Senior | |
| Linebacker | |||
| Jordan Peterson | Arrowhead | Senior | |
| Jacob Laux | Kettle Moraine | Senior | |
| Tyler Brusky | Pius XI | Senior | |
| Secondary | |||
| Nate Angles | Waukesha West | Senior | |
| Justin Boller | Waukesha West | Senior | |
| Nick Tehan | Waukesha West | Junior | |
| Punter | |||
| Drew Meyer | Arrowhead | Junior | |
| Everett Scott | Kettle Moraine | Senior | |
| Honorable Mention | |||
| Interior Lineman | |||
| Nick Schoenheider | Arrowhead | Junior | |
| Alex Cochrane | Kettle Moraine | Junior | |
| Seth Storment | Mukwonago | Senior | |
| Joe Kordasiewicz | Waukesha South | Junior | |
| Defensive End | |||
| Dustin Austin | Waukesha North | Junior | |
| Rob Anderson | Waukesha South | Junior | |
| Linebacker | |||
| Matt Bernhardt | Catholic Memorial | Senior | |
| Garett Wescott | Kettle Moraine | Senior | |
| SpencerKranz | Mukwonago | Senior | |
| Brad Csedo | Waukesha North | Senior | |
| Drew Papez | Waukesha Soth | Junior | |
| Dallas Ramos-Deleon | Waukesha West | Junior | |
| Secondary | |||
| Jake Poehls | Arrowhead | Senior | |
| Jerry Boll | Catholic Memorial | Junior | |
| Pat Hale | Catholic Memorial | Senior | |
| Mitch Schultz | Catholic Memorial | Senior | |
| Jacob Lindmair | Mukwonago | Senior | |
| Ty Baushchek | Mukwonago | Senior | |
| Evan Richarz | Pius XI | Sophomore | |
| Matt Jipson | Waukesha West | Senior | |
| Punter | |||
| Tyler Brusky | Pius XI | Senior | |
| Ryan Kiser | Waukesha West | Senior | |