| 2009-10 Hockey All Conference | ||
| Player of the Year: Brian Berger | Arrowhead | Senior |
| 1st Team Forwards | ||
| Nick Szalacinski | Arrowhead | Senior |
| Tom Chapin | Cath Mem/Pius | Senior |
| Max Carrigan | Waukesha | Senior |
| 1st Team Defense | ||
| Matt Fosdick | Brookfield | Sophomore |
| Cody Dixon | Cath Mem/Pius | Junior |
| 1st Team Goalie | ||
| Michael Parda | Waukesha | Senior |
| 2nd Team Forwards | ||
| Justin Yute | K Moraine/Mukwonago | Sophomore |
| Tyler Vermey | Waukesha | Junior |
| Max Pierson | Kenosha | Senio |
| 2nd Team Defense | ||
| Donovan Blakney | Arrowhead | Senior |
| John Dobson | Waukesha | Senior |
| 2nd Team Goalie | ||
| David Chapin | Cath Mem/Pius | Senior |
| Honorable Mention Forwards | ||
| Mike Herrick | Arrowhead | Senior |
| Colton Sweitzer | Arrowhead | Junior |
| Kyle Fink | Cath Mem/Pius | Junior |
| Anthony Soo Hoo | Cath Mem/Pius | Junior |
| Kyler Schmor | K Moraine/Mukwonago | Junior |
| Nate Freeman | K Moraine/Mukwonago | Senior |
| Bobby Theis | Ocon/Pewk/SJ/UL | Junior |
| Max Culp | Waukesha | Senior |
| Honorable Mention Defense | ||
| Tony Koehler | Arrowhead | Junior |
| Harrison Aghjian | Brookfield | Senior |
| P J Corbett | Brookfield | Sophomore |
| Mitch DeMario | Greendale/Franklin/OC/ML | Sophomore |
| Alex Zukauskas | Waukesha | Senior |
| Cody Colbert | Kenosha | Senior |
| Honorable Mention Goalie | ||
| Tyler Platz | K Moraine/Mukwonago | Sophomore |
| Nick Hollandoner | Kenosha | Senior |