| Boys Soccer 2009 All Conference | ||
| Player of the Year | ||
| Kyle Peterson | Arrowhead | Senior |
| 1st Team Forwards | ||
| Andy Fox | Arrowhead | Senior |
| Michael Schlecht | Mukwonago | Senior |
| 2nd Team Forwards | ||
| Aaron Horvat | Catholic Memorial | Sophomore |
| James Mahoney | Kettle Moraine | Senior |
| Honorable Mention Forwards | ||
| Wade Nelson | Mukwonago | Senior |
| Victor Hernandez | Pius XI | Senior |
| Robert Holschuh | Pius XI | Freshman |
| Matthew Rynders | Waukesha North | Senior |
| Max Finke | Waukesha South | Senior |
| Ryan Doughty | Waukesha West | Senior |
| 1st Team Midfielder | ||
| Jordan Dai | Arrowhead | Senior |
| Alden Bennet | Catholic Memorial | Senior |
| John Mau | Kettle Moraine | Senior |
| Jared Kobriger | Kettle Moraine | Junior |
| 2nd Team Midfielder | ||
| Austin Zimmerman | Mukwonago | Junior |
| Jan Hulvrt | Pius XI | Junior |
| Barandyn Banazynski | Waukesha North | Senior |
| Cody Trapp | Waukesha West | Senior |
| Honorable Mention Midfielder | ||
| Danny Ziegler | Arrowhead | Senior |
| Joey Chiappetta | Catholic Memorial | Senior |
| Matt Lange | Kettle Moraine | Senior |
| Michael Montanye | Mukwonago | Senior |
| Goyko Rajak | Pius XI | Senior |
| Paul Dynis | Waukesha North | Senior |
| 1st Team Defense | ||
| Mike Skarie | Arrowhead | Senior |
| EricSchoendorf | Catholic Memorial | Junior |
| Ryan Schultz | Kettle Moraine | Junior |
| Noah Bularz | Mukwonago | Senior |
| Dan Cerroni | Waukesha West | Junior |
| 2nd Team Defense | ||
| Robbie Denniston | Arrowhead | Senior |
| Denzel Pettigrew | Pius XI | Senior |
| Billy Fank | Waukesha North | Junior |
| Honorable Mention Defense | ||
| Brian Griffin | Arrowhead | Senior |
| Karl Kallio | Catholic Memorial | Senior |
| Thomas J Krause | Pius XI | Junior |
| Corbin Wellford | Waukesha South | Junior |
| Jake Coxey | Waukesha West | Senior |
| Tim McCue | Waukesha West | Senior |
| 1st Team Goalkeeper | ||
| Josh Rohde | Waukesha West | Junior |
| 2nd Team Goalkeeper | ||
| Max Jentsch | Arrwhead | Senior |
| Honorable Mention Goalkeeper | ||
| Tim Shore | Catholic Memorial | Senior |
| Mike Nowak | Pius XI | Senior |
| Jonathon Stewart | Waukesha South | Senior |