| Girls Golf 2009 All Conference | |
| Player of the Year: Emily Joers | Waukesha |
| Isabella Lambert | Catholic Memorial |
| April Ohlendorf | Kettle Moraine |
| Erika Pfaender | Arrowhead |
| Amanda Braun | Pius XI |
| Sarah Nordeen | Arrowhead |
| 2nd Team | |
| Bethany Gustin | Arrowhead |
| Brandi Rajala | Waukesha |
| Anna Volbrecht | Kettle Moraine |
| Natalie Feder | Arrowhead |
| Leighann Cabush | Kettle Moraine |
| Honorable Mention | |
| Kate Geraghty | Pius XI |
| Emily Bliske | Pius XI |
| Lauren Seubert | Catholic Memorial |
| Jordan Nichols | Mukwonago |
| Ally Amadon | Kettle Moraine |