| Girls Tennis 2009 All Conference | ||||
| Player of the Year: Katy Allen | Waukesha South | Junior | ||
| 1st Team Singles | ||||
| Aimee Balistreri | Pius XI | Junior | ||
| Heather Bong | Arrowhead | Junior | ||
| Stacey Bjorgaard | Kettle Moraine | Senior | ||
| 2nd Team | ||||
| Kelly Johnson | Waukesha South | Junior | ||
| Tracy Murn | Catholic Memorial | Senior | ||
| Ali Fuller | Kettle Moraine | Senior | ||
| Mary Hinzey | Arrowhead | Sophomore | ||
| Honorable Mention | ||||
| Allie Mroczkowski | Mukwonago | Senior | ||
| Angie Greenman | Waukesha North | Junior | ||
| Amy Zhou | Waukesha West | Freshman | ||
| Gabrielle Houk | Catholic Memorial | Sophomore | ||
| Katie Klokner | Mukwonago | Junior | ||
| Midori Higuchi | Pius XI | Junior | ||
| Maria Bucci | Waukesha North | Senior | ||
| 1st Team Doubles | ||||
| Jessica Phillips | Freshman | Zoe Roecker | Senior | Kettle Moraine |
| Karlie LaVeau | Junior | Erica VanRiper | Junior | Waukesha South |
| Abby Kolbow | Freshman | Rachel Bero | Sophomore | Arrowhead |
| 2nd Team Doubles | ||||
| Delrae Felton | Senior | Bridget Cahill | Junior | Waukesha North |
| Claire Parrott | Senior | Morgan Horneck | Junior | Kettle Moraine |
| Whitney DuPaix | Senior | Caitlin Gardner | Junior | Waukesha West |
| Honorable Mention Doubles | ||||
| Aleah Heinlein | Senior | MacKenzie Dunham | Senior | Catholic Memorial |
| Emily Budzynski | Senior | Courtney Persinger | Senior | Mukwonago |
| Shoniqua Reik | Senior | Hannah Pringle | Senior | Pius XI |
| Keelan Schoenecker | Senior | Julia Mauer | Senior | Arrowhead |
| Maggie Berens | Senior | Meg Dwyer | Senior | Catholic Memorial |
| Sarah Paese | Senior | Caitlin Journey | Senior | Pius XI |
| Megan Johnson | Senior | Becca Morgan | Junior | Waukesha South |