| 1st Team Offense | ||
| Center | ||
| Matt Plutschack | Mukwonago | Sr |
| Guard | ||
| Mark Semrad | Catholic Memorial | Sr |
| Derek Schmidt | Waukesha West | Sr |
| Tackle | ||
| Joe Pulczinski | Mukwonago | Jr |
| Jeremy Clark | Waukesha South | Sr |
| Receivers | ||
| Jim Landwehr | Arrowhead | Sr |
| Peter Scalish | Catholic Memorial | Sr |
| Running Back | ||
| Bruce Zalud | Mukwonago | Sr |
| Jeff Garcia | Mukwonago | Sr |
| Steve Spratte | Waukesha West | Soph |
| Quarterback | ||
| John Witte | Mukwonago | Sr |
| Placekicker | ||
| John Hoch | Arrowhead | Sr |
| Offensive Player of the Year | ||
| John Witte | Mukwonago | Sr |
| 2nd Team Offense | ||
| Center | ||
| A J Kuenzi | Waukesha West | Sr |
| Guard | ||
| Matt Nelson | Arrowhead | Sr |
| Brett Stegerwald | Mukwonago | Sr |
| Tackle | ||
| Alex Helling | Waukesha West | Sr |
| Aaron Krason | Waukesha West | Jr |
| Receivers | ||
| Scott Spexarth | Mukwonago | Sr |
| Sean McCarty | Waukesha West | Jr |
| Running Back | ||
| Drew Volkmann | Arrowhead | Jr |
| Ben Hackbart | Arrowhead | Sr |
| Guy dragonetti | Catholic Memorial | Sr |
| Quarterback | ||
| Brian Kuhtz | Waukesha North | Jr |
| Place Kicker | ||
| Ben Will | Mukwonago | Sr |
| Honorable Mention Offense | ||
| Center | ||
| Bill Krueger | Arrowhead | Jr |
| Justin Becker | Kettle Moraine | Sr |
| Guard | ||
| Zach Dunbar | Kettle Moraine | Sr |
| Andeen Jett | Pius XI | Jr |
| Luke Nabak | Waukesha North | Jr |
| Nick Vetta | Waukesha West | Sr |
| Tackle | ||
| Keith Queoff | Pius XI | |
| Dan Foy | Pius XI | Jr |
| Ben Stellmacher | Waukesha North | Sr |
| Receivers | ||
| Jackson Whitehead | Kettle Moraine | Jr |
| Micah Thompson | Mukwonago | Sr |
| Josh Gibbs | Waukesha North | Sr |
| Dustin Wagner | Waukesha South | Sr |
| Scott Krause | Waukesha West | Sr |
| Running Back | ||
| Casey Casper | Kettle Moraine | Soph |
| Jeff Dunlap | Waukesha South | Sr |
| Bobby Orzech | Waukesha West | Jr |
| Quarterback | ||
| Kyle Notch | Waukesha West | Jr |
| Place Kicker | ||
| Ryan O'Laire | Arrowhead | Sr |
| Rob Redford | Waukesha North | Sr |
| Defense | ||
| 1st Team Interior Lineman | ||
| Kent Hock | Mukwonago | Sr |
| Jeremy Clark | Waukesha South | Sr |
| Austin Brunet | Waukesha West | Sr |
| 2nd Team Interior Lineman | ||
| Mark Semrad | Catholic Memorial | Sr |
| Jeff Trinka | Mukwonago | Jr |
| Dustin Ratelle | Waukesha North | Sr |
| Adam MacDonald | Waukesha West | Sr |
| Honorable Mention Interior Lineman | ||
| Cory Wise | Arrowhead | Sr |
| Labinot Hallai | Arrowhead | Sr |
| Josh Schindler | Kettle Moraine | Sr |
| Peter Drozd | Mukwonago | Sr |
| Eric Pinon | Pius XI | Sr |
| 1st Team Defensive End | ||
| Ben Will | Mukwonago | Sr |
| Tyler Zimmerman | Waukesha West | Sr |
| 2nd Team Defensive End | ||
| Jason Jankowski | Arrowhead | Sr |
| Patrick Butrym | Catholic Memorial | Jr |
| Keith Queoff | Pius XI | Sr |
| Honorable Mention Defensive End | ||
| Pat Kurkiewicz | Kettle Moraine | Sr |
| Don Kujawa | Mukwonago | Sr |
| Chris Pilon | Waukesha South | Sr |
| 1st Team Linebacker | ||
| Greg Arnold | Mukwonago | Jr |
| Chad Zimborski | Waukesha North | Sr |
| Ryan Becker | Waukesha West | Sr |
| 2nd Team Linebacker | ||
| Sam Anderson | Arrowhead | Sr |
| Josh Williams | Mukwonago | Sr |
| Frank Nellen | Pius XI | Sr |
| Honorable Mention Linebacker | ||
| Guy Dragonetti | Catholic Memorial | Sr |
| Kyle Carpenter | Catholic Memorial | Sr |
| Blake Rowe | Kettle Moraine | Sr |
| 1st Team Secondary | ||
| Sam Mosey | Arrowhead | Sr |
| Peter Scalish | Catholic Memorial | |
| Tyler Mueller | Mukwonago | Sr |
| 2nd Team Secondary | ||
| Mike Spaight | Mukwonago | Soph |
| Rob Redford | Waukesha North.Sr | |
| Aaron Hunkins | Waukesha West | Jr |
| Honorable Mention Secondary | ||
| Kyle Rogan | Kettle Moraine | Sr |
| Zach Young | Mukwonago | Sr |
| Sean Saglin | Pius XI | Jr |
| Dustin Wagner | Waukesha South | Sr |
| 1st Team Punter | ||
| David Schwerman | Kettle Moraine | Soph |
| 2nd Team Punter | ||
| Mike Smith | Catholic Memorial | Jr |
| Honorable Mention Punter | ||
| Scott Spexarth | Mukwonago | Sr |
| Tim Pauly | Pius XI | Sr |
| Defensive Player Of The Year | ||
| Ben Will | Mukwonago | Sr |
| Coach Of The Year | ||
| Steve Rux | Waukesha West | |
| Assistant Coach Of The Year | ||
| Bill Schulte | Mukwonago | |